November 19, 2026
At the end of October 2026, Columbus REALTORS counted 78 homes for sale in the City of Westerville. The same organization's October 2026 report for the Westerville City School District counted 190. The school district says its boundaries include all or parts of Blendon Township, Columbus, Westerville, Genoa Township, Plain Township, Sharon Township and the Village of Minerva Park.
The larger footprint had more than twice as many homes for sale as the city. Across those jurisdictions, the fire department, the police, the water company, the electric provider and the property tax line can all change. This fall, Westerville's market has loosened enough that buyers can compare those differences before they write an offer.
The city report covers both sides of the county line, Franklin and Delaware. In October 2026 it showed 78 homes for sale, up from 44 in October 2025, and 1.9 months of supply, up from 1.1. New listings rose to 54 from 38 over the same months. Days on market until sale held at 21 for October in both years, and sellers received 98.3 percent of their original list price in October 2026.
The city's October median sale price was $490,000, up 17 percent from a year earlier, but it rests on 31 closings. The year-to-date median through October 2026 was $449,950, up 4.7 percent, and it better describes where prices sit. The school district report for October 2026 showed a $444,950 median on 85 closings. The two medians are close. The bigger difference between the two reports is how many of the school district's listings sit outside the city.
Much of the territory outside the city has names Westerville buyers will recognize. Blendon Township's 2026 resident guide describes the township as a number of "islands" mainly surrounded by the City of Westerville, the City of Columbus, Plain Township and Genoa Township. It names Sunbury Woods, Huber Ridge, Hamstead, Glengary Heights, Glengary Woods, Cleveland Heights, Gould Park, Rolling Ridge, areas east of Hoover Reservoir and the Village of Minerva Park.
Some services there still come from Westerville. According to the same guide, Blendon Township contracts with the City of Westerville's Fire Division for fire and EMS service. Station 112 at 727 East Schrock Road is the station closest to Blendon and the one that most often answers its calls. Other services follow township lines. Blendon has its own police department for its unincorporated areas, Rumpke handles trash, and water comes from Aqua Ohio west of Hoover Reservoir and Del-Co east of it. The guide lists AEP as the electric contact. Inside the city, Westerville's own electric division serves residents and businesses. For a house near Hoover Reservoir, the water provider depends on which side of the reservoir it is on.
The Delaware County side has its own pattern. Genoa Township runs its own fire department, which responds around the clock across a primary area of 21.5 square miles. The township's comprehensive plan, revised in 2019, describes Genoa parcels south of Polaris Parkway and south of County Line Road as unincorporated islands surrounded by Westerville. The same plan places Westerville City Schools in the township's south, Olentangy Local Schools in its northwest and Big Walnut Local Schools in its northeast.
Within the city limits, the Delaware County side is split into more than one district. The Delaware County Auditor's tax year 2025 sheet lists two separate lines for the city, Westerville Corp.-Westerville and Westerville Corp.-Olentangy.
Each of these jurisdictions has its own line on the county auditors' published rate sheets. The Franklin County sheet is titled "2025 Property Tax Rates for 2026." The Delaware County sheet covers tax year 2025, and the Delaware County Auditor's January 2026 statement addresses the tax year 2025 bills residents pay in 2026. The table lists the published effective residential rates for the lines carrying the Westerville name.
| County | District as listed | Effective residential rate, per $1,000 assessed |
|---|---|---|
| Franklin | Columbus-Westerville CSD | 55.896002 |
| Franklin | Blendon Twp-Cols-Westerville | 56.496002 |
| Delaware | Westerville Corp.-Westerville | 56.882112 |
| Delaware | Genoa-Westerville | 60.669319 |
| Delaware | Westerville Corp.-Olentangy | 62.662927 |
| Franklin | City of Westerville | 63.585888 |
| Franklin | Westerville-Blendon Twp-Westerville | 64.185888 |
| Franklin | Columbus-Plain Twp-Westerville | 64.876664 |
| Franklin | Plain Twp-Westerville CSD | 66.799596 |
| Franklin | Sharon Twp-Westerville CSD | 68.318718 |
Property values are changing as well. The Franklin County Auditor is carrying out its 2026 triennial update, and the Delaware County Auditor has posted proposed 2026 values. These figures are general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Confirm what applies to a specific property with the county auditor or a qualified tax professional.
Last October, with 1.1 months of supply in the city, buyers had little time to look past price and condition. With 1.9 months of supply and 54 new listings in October 2026, they have more. Two Westerville listings at similar prices this winter can differ in which department answers a fire call, which company sends the water bill, which utility supplies the power and which line of the rate sheet the property falls on. A buyer can ask about all of these during a showing, and the current pace of the market leaves time to do it.
Sellers outside the city limits can use the same information. A listing in Huber Ridge or Sunbury Woods competes for many of the same buyers as a listing near Uptown Westerville, and a listing that tells buyers up front who provides each service answers their questions before they ask. Our Westerville neighborhood page has more on the area.
If you're weighing Westerville listings on both sides of the city line this winter, or getting ready to sell a home with a Westerville address outside it, Deborah Parris can pull the service providers, parcel records and recent sales for the specific addresses you're considering. If you're selling, start with a free home valuation based on the part of Westerville your home is actually in.
Your Next move starts with a conversation.